Skip to product information
🍳✨ Product Overview ✨🍳
This is a fully restored vintage cast iron skillet, a classic Wagner Ware Sidney O #4 Skillet. This piece of high-quality collectible cookware features the iconic "WAGNER WARE SIDNEY -O-" logo on the bottom, with the distinct pattern number "1054 A." It has a beautifully smooth cooking surface, and two pour spouts, making it a functional and beautiful addition to any kitchen. This #4 size is rare, highly collectible, and perfect for single servings or small side dishes.
🔥 Manufacturer Synopsis 🔥
The Wagner Manufacturing Company of Sidney, Ohio, has a legacy of producing some of the finest cast iron cookware ever made. This Wagner Ware Sidney O skillet is a prime example of their dedication to quality, originating from the 1930s to the 1950s. During this period, Wagner was known for its innovative casting techniques that resulted in thinner, lighter, and smoother pans than many of their competitors. These skillets are celebrated for their incredible balance and superior heat distribution, making them a favorite for both everyday cooking and serious collecting.
⭐ Physical Condition ⭐
This skillet has been meticulously inspected and rated on our cast iron condition scale.
+ Crack Condition: 5 (Perfect: Absolutely no evidence of any cracks, past or present.)
+ Spin Condition: 3.5 (A balanced rating that indicates a slight, but noticeable, rotation when nudged on a perfectly flat surface, which is often a normal characteristic of vintage cast iron and does not compromise cooking.)
+ Wobble Condition: 4 (Excellent (Minimal Wobble): Tiny, imperceptible movement that settles instantly.)
+ Interior Surface Rating: 4.5 (A custom rating indicating a balance between perfection and minor blemishes, signifying a near-perfect cooking surface with only the most minimal, isolated imperfections.)
+ Exterior Surface Rating: 5 (Perfect (No Exterior Blemishes): The exterior surfaces (sides, bottom, handle) are uniformly smooth with absolutely no visible pitting, scratches, and/or flea-bites.)
📏 Physical Dimensions 📏
+ Diameter: Approximately 7 inches / 18 cm
+ Depth: Approximately 1.5 inches / 3.8 cm
+ Overall Length: Approximately 11 inches / 28 cm
+ Approximate Weight: Approximately 2 lbs 8 oz / 1.1 kg
✨ Restoration Process ✨
This vintage cast iron piece has undergone a professional, multi-step restoration to return it to its full glory. We begin with a ~1M (Molar) Sodium Hydroxide lye bath to thoroughly strip away all carbon buildup and old seasoning. Following this, the skillet is placed in an electrolysis tank for ~10 Amperes (A) of hydrolysis, a gentle process that meticulously removes all traces of rust without damaging the precious iron. The final and most crucial step is a triple oven seasoning using Flaxseed Oil. This creates a durable, beautiful, and naturally non-stick finish, making it ready to use right out of the box!
👀 Key Highlights 👀
This fully restored skillet isn't just a piece of Made in USA history; it's an investment in your cooking and your collection.
+ Superior Cookware: With its even heat distribution and smooth surface, this skillet is a fantastic everyday user, perfect for single-serving dishes, searing steaks, frying eggs, or making cornbread.
+ Collectible Value: As a genuine heirloom quality Wagner Ware with the classic Sidney O markings, this piece is a cornerstone for any serious cast iron collection.
+ Durability and Longevity: Having already lasted for decades, this skillet is a testament to the enduring quality of early cast iron. Properly cared for, it will continue to be a centerpiece in your kitchen for many more generations.
+ Eco-Friendly: By choosing restored vintage cookware, you're making a sustainable choice and helping to reduce waste, contributing to a greener planet while acquiring a piece with character and history.
📦 Packaging/Shipping Options 📦
(1) Eco-Friendly: Giving Boxes a Second Act!
We're all about sustainability here! To minimize waste, we frequently reuse clean, sturdy shipping materials. So, don't be surprised if your box has a little character – it's just playing its role in helping the environment (and our budget!).
(2) New packaging is always an option if you prefer; just ask! We use primarily paper/cardboard to minimize our plastic footprint.
Disclaimer:
Parts of this description were created with Google Gemini AI [1.5 Pro] using a highly targeted and meticulously crafted prompt for a high degree of accuracy.
Additionally:
Please feel free to reach out if you have any questions, special requests, or would like a physical confirmation of the items dimensions.

$250.00